Showing posts with label ICAI Election 2009: Regional Council. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ICAI Election 2009: Regional Council. Show all posts

10 February 2010

IndianCAs: WIRC Office Bearers for year 2010-11

 

So ultimately the D day came. Newly elected members conducted their informal meeting to elect their office bearers. The combination of Sanjeev Lalan, Shrinivas Joshi and Durgesh Kabra is in power now. They succeeded in wooing the newly regional council members. Here is the year 1 office Bearers:

 

Chairman : Sanjeev Lalan, Mumbai

Vice-Chairman: Makrand Joshi, Nagpur

Secretary : Mangesh Kinare, Mumbai

Treasurer : Parag Raval, Ahmedabad

 

So congratulations to all office bearers!!

 

You can wish them on IndianCAs blog below:

http://indiancas.blogspot.com/2010/02/new-office-bearer-of-wirc-elected.html


 

| Ashwin Nagar | FCA and SAP-FICO\SEM-BCS |
Success is not permanent and failure is not final
Ph: India: +91-98330-15352  US: +1-323-325-4111
 
Twitter      : http://twitter.com/ashwinnagar

__._,_.___
We are on Facebook, join:
http://www.facebook.com/?filter=app_2361831622#!/group.php?gid=144654990478&ref=nf
***************************************************************************
Please visit the blog of IndianCAs and Express yourself by writing your comments by clicking on the link below:
http://indiancas.blogspot.com/
***************************************************************************
Hi! I have created an sms group for the benefit of members of IndianCAs. I will be sending regular updates, good quotes.If you wish to subscribe to this group, send following sms to 9870807070

ON IndianCAs

You will receive an sms from group. Just reply the message by writing:
Agree
And you will be the member of my SMS group IndianCAs.You can unsubscribe at any point of time by sendin an sms Off IndianCAs. There is no charge for receiving sms. So  let's Go Mobile.
*************************************************************************
Note: All messages posted by members including me on this group are sent in their personal capacity. No official position held anywhere by them have nothing to do with this email group. The group does   not accept any responsibility with regards to accuracy or the mistakes in the material circulated on this group. Please confirm from your independent source before using the information or material posted on this group.
*************************************************************************
Further, your attention is invited:

The messages on this group are approved only when the moderator finds it of immense importance to the members at general, otherwise, this group is not used for discussion or as discussion forum.
.

__,_._,___

05 January 2010

WIRC Office Bearers Combination - 2

Welcome Back.
So now the combination 2. Why, because Combination 1 has got many problems. Many people and limited posts.

  • Vadodara has historically getting position of vice-chairmanship and Vadodara has always been with the winning combination. This time Vadodara is in problem. The challenges are from Surat for the position of vice-chairmanship. Not only Surat, but Pune is also putting a big challenge to the combination and claiming vice-chairmanship. So Who will get this position in addition to B K Patel and Makrand Joshi? Very interesting. If you want to take my view, Vadodara is trusted and old companion, so I bet on Vadodara, Rajesh Bhai, congratulations!!
  • Surat is a growing economy and crunching a large no. of chartered accountants every year. Surat has also become politically very active. Historically Surat was always with Mumbai candidates, but now since B K Rathi, Surat wants to make its on presence felt and want to play a role in the region. Surat has proved at many occasions that its not behind Vadodara in any case. It was inactive but it doesn't mean, its incapable. So you can't right off the Surat's claim so easily. Best of Luck Jay Chhaira!!
  • Pune is as big or bigger than Ahmedabad. if Ahmedabad gets vice-chairmanship why not Pune. Only problem is that my humble friend Dinesh Gandhi is very sober person. He doesn't believe in position. He is happy even if he gets and even if not.
  • C V Pawar is also claimiant for vice-chairmanship, but I think he has been sidelined by the current combination and most likely he will have to find the address of the coffee shop at cuffe parade which I mentioned in my earlier post.
  • Secretaries are fixed and happy. Anil Bhandari, Mangesh Kinare and Shardul Shah. No other challenger.
  • Treasurership too has become a bone of contention. One of the two Vadodara or Surat will get it. Dinesh Gandhi will another claimaint along with Julfesh Shah. Parag too is there to claim it. So one of the two Parag or Julfesh will get it.

So looking at all this, I think Combination 2 too is working. How?

Chairmen:

  • N C Hegde
  • Sunil Patodia
  • Durgesh Kabra

Vice-Charimen:

  • Jay Chhaira
  • C V Pawar
  • Rajesh Shah

Secretary:

  • Anil Bhandari
  • Parag Raval
  • Vishnu Agarwal

Treasurer:

  • Julfesh Shah
  • Neel Majithia
  • Diensh Gandhi

  • What will happen to Ashok Jain? I understand, he is a force in himself, so he will not be part of any group. He will remain out whichever combination succeeds.
  • You forgot Dhiraj Khandelwal? No I didn't, I think its a cooling period for his chairmanship claim. He has really worked very hard in his last term.
  • Shruti Shah and Dilip Apte will not take any position so far.

What do you think about this combination? And its possibility? Explore till the first combination settle their problems.

03 January 2010

WIRC: Who will make office bearer of WIRC? Combination 1

Hi! Welcome back. Now let us discuss the various combinations. Here is the combination 1:

Chairmen:

  • Shrinivas Joshi
  • Sanjeev Lalan
  • Durgesh Kabara

(Variation available is N C Hegde in place of Durgesh Kabra, if N C Hegde is in, Anil Bhandari and Durgesh Kabra will be out of this combination.)

Vice-Chairmen:

  • Makrand Joshi
  • B K Patel
  • Rajesh Shah

(If Anil Bhandari insist on becoming secretary, C V Pawar will have to be accommodated here, then who will be out? No one can be out, these three are very very strong contender, interesting..)

Secretaries:

  • Mangesh Kinare
  • Shardul Shah
  • C V Pawar

(Variation available is Anil Bhandari instead of C V Pawar, in that case C V Pawar will have to be adjusted in Vice-chairmanship and in VC there is no vacancy at all, very very interesting!!)

Treasurers:

  • Dinesh Gandhi
  • Jay Chhaira
  • Anil Bhandari

(Variation available is Parag Raval instead of whom? I don't know. Most likely Parag Raval will not be in office bearer ship, may be he get chairmanship of WICASA)

How is this combination? Comment... I will get back to you with Combination 2 soon.

02 January 2010

Final Result of Regional Council election for NIRC

Sr. No.

Name of Candidate

Total No. of Votes

13 

CA. Garg Vishal 

1172

15 

CA. Gupta Atul Kumar 

1092

20 

CA. Kedia Gopal Kumar 

1091

CA. Agrawal Durga Das 

1091

12 

CA. Chugh Hans Raj 

1091

27 

CA. Sharma Rajesh 

1091

23 

CA. Maheshwari Pramod Kumar 

1005

CA. Agrawal Sanjay Kumar 

978

CA. Agrawal Deen Dayal 

849

24 

CA. Mittal Mohan Lal 

845

21 

CA. Khetrapal Rashmi (Ms.) 

823

14 

CA. Goel Rajiv 

707

Who will rule WIRC for next three years? Part-2

  • Last heard, the group has been formed. But let me keep this secret for the moment. Let us discuss something else and raise your curiosity before I disclose what is latest in the market.
  • Who are the chairman candidates? Here are the claimants (Only three will make it):
    • N C Hegde
    • Shrinivas Joshi
    • Sunil Patodia
    • Durgesh Kabra
    • Sanjeev Lalan
    • Ashok Jain
  • Who are the aspirants for vice-chairmanship? 
    • B K Patel
    • Makrand Joshi
    • Rajesh Shah
    • C V Pawar
    • Jay Chhaira
    • Julfesh Shah
    • Dinesh Gandhi
  • Honorary secretaries list:
    •  Mangesh Kinare
    • Anil Bhandari
    • Vishnu Agarwal
    • Shardul Shah
    • Parag Raval
    • Neel Majithia
  • Who is claiming Treasurership?
    • None
    • Historically nobody wants to become treasurership. The treasurership is only thrust upon. All members from outside Mumbai, wants to become vice-chairman, and all Mumbai members want to become secretary. But in the No's game, people need to sacrifice. And all who sacrifice, are thrust upon the most prestigious Treasurership, giving the first right to sign the Balance Sheet of WIRC.
  • Who are likely to be thrust upon the treasurership:
    • Parag Raval
    • Dinesh Gandhi
    • Jay Chhaira
    • Julfesh Shah
  • Who doesn't want to be office bearer in this term?
    • Shruti Shah
    • Dilip Apte
Remember, I have listed many names, but only 3 in each category will get the posts, depends upon which like minded people agrees to serve the WIRC as office bearers.
 
Though the list has narrowed down. But to keep this interesting, keep your anxiety on and expecting more hits on this blog, I am not disclosing things till some like minded people gathering today to discuss the positions complete their meeting. I willl tell you in third series who have decided to get together, what problems they are going to face and how difficult have become for them to agree on these limited office bearer ship.
 
Can we have something like joint-secretary or General Secretary to accommodate all? Hehehe.. I am kidding..

Who will rule WIRC for next three years? Part-1

  • After each election results, the next question arises, who will form the government? In our system of council, there is no government or opposition. There are twelve people who become office bearer at WIRC and there are ten people who doesn't. That's it :)
  • There are certain conventions in WIRC:
    • Any member can take only one position as an office bearer in his or her term of three years as a regional council members. For example, if Mr. Good Hope became chairman in WIRC in first year of his term, he will not take any other position of office bearer in whole term of three years.
    • By this convention, 12 people can enjoy any position of office bearer ship in a term of three years. Chairman, Vice-chairman, Secretary and Treasurer, Four office bearer in each year and twelve in three years.
    • What makes you an office bearer? A vote of majority. So what is majority? out of total twenty two member, the magic figure of majority is twelve. Did you notice, the no. of office bearer ship available as per convention in three years is also twelve. So any twelve like minded people coming together, decides to hold one position each in whole term, makes them in majority.
    • Before formal election for office bearer is held in regional council, an informal meeting of all members is conducted wherein the office bearers are elected. In formal meeting of regional council, all office bearers are elected unanimously. This convention too very old. It was only heard once broken when a revolutionary lady with the lamp, decided to do everything formal and on record.
    • And these groups generally last for all three years. Last heard these group broken was long back when our one of the presidents became chairman of WIRC in last year of his term against old odds. And that incident is giving forever lots of unfulfilled hopes to those ten left outs.
  • And therefore, who will be twelve office bearers of WIRC for the next three years is decided upfront in the beginning of the term, though informally. Sometimes it becomes public, sometimes not. It all depends on the ability of members to stomach the information.
  • Then what happens to the rest of ten people who are left out? They do get chairmanship of at least one sub-committee, and if you are in race of office bearer ship, you may end up getting the chairmanship of most coveted sub-committee Library Committee.
  • Now it all depends on you. Can you put in your efforts without getting any office bearer ship? If yes, there is scope in each committee to work and deliver. You may get some sub committee where you may think no scope to work, but it all depends on your innovative approach and out of box thinking power, that you can turn any committee into an important delivering committee.
  • If you can't deliver without getting any office bearer ship, then you will have to wait for another three years. Get like minded left out people together, find a good coffee shop in Colaba and have an evening there after each regional council or committee meeting and discussing in cloud of smoke, what would have happened if X would not have gone with them or Y would have agreed to be in your combination.
  • Sounds interesting? It is. How do you find this? Please comment below.

01 January 2010

NIRC: Details of Votes of Regional Council at elimination of Rakesh Varshney

Sr. No.

Name of Candidate

Total No. of Votes

13 

CA. Garg Vishal 

1172

15 

CA. Gupta Atul Kumar 

1092

20 

CA. Kedia Gopal Kumar 

1091

CA. Agrawal Durga Das 

1091

12 

CA. Chugh Hans Raj 

1091

27 

CA. Sharma Rajesh 

1043

23 

CA. Maheshwari Pramod Kumar 

999

CA. Agrawal Sanjay Kumar 

941

CA. Agrawal Deen Dayal 

828

24 

CA. Mittal Mohan Lal 

817

21 

CA. Khetrapal Rashmi (Ms.) 

744

CA. Bansal Radhey Shyam 

698

14 

CA. Goel Rajiv 

654

26 

CA. Seth Raman Kumar 

595

25 

CA. Narang Rajinder 

591

Details of Votes of Regional Council of NIRC after elimination of Niraj Jain

Sr. No.

Name of Candidate

Total No. of Votes

13

CA. Garg Vishal

1172

15

CA. Gupta Atul Kumar

1092

20

CA. Kedia Gopal Kumar

1065

12

CA. Chugh Hans Raj

977

2

CA. Agrawal Durga Das

967

27

CA. Sharma Rajesh

930

23

CA. Maheshwari Pramod Kumar

907

4

CA. Agrawal Sanjay Kumar

811

24

CA. Mittal Mohan Lal

753

1

CA. Agrawal Deen Dayal

695

21

CA. Khetrapal Rashmi (Ms.)

654

26

CA. Seth Raman Kumar

597

9

CA. Bansal Radhey Shyam

586

14

CA. Goel Rajiv

575

25

CA. Narang Rajinder

556

28

CA. Varshney Rakesh

520

8

CA. Bansal Puneet Kumar

512

5

CA. Agrawal Sunil Kumar

459

Details of votes of Regional Council results of NIRC

Sr. No.

Name of Candidate

Votes

13

CA. Garg Vishal  

Elected

15

CA. Gupta Atul Kumar

1056

20

CA. Kedia Gopal Kumar

880

27

CA. Sharma Rajesh  

835

23

CA. Maheshwari Pramod Kumar

818

2

CA. Agrawal Durga Das

814

12

CA. Chugh Hans Raj

784

24

CA. Mittal Mohan Lal

686

4

CA. Agrawal Sanjay Kumar

676

1

CA. Agrawal Deen Dayal

603

26

CA. Seth Raman Kumar

546

25

CA. Narang Rajinder  

510

9

CA. Bansal Radhey Shyam

505

21

CA. Khetrapal Rashmi (Ms.)

502

3

CA. Agrawal Rajesh Kumar

452

14

CA. Goel Rajiv  

445

28

CA. Varshney Rakesh  

438

8

CA. Bansal Puneet Kumar

387

5

CA. Agrawal Sunil Kumar

337

6

CA. Anil Kumar  

312

10

CA. Chawla Raj Kumar

311

19

CA. Jain Neeraj  

309

11

CA. Choudhary Mahak Singh

306

16

CA. Gupta Rekha Kumari (Ms.)

233

18

CA. Jain Gaurav  

208

17

CA. Gupta Suresh Kumar

125

7

CA. Ashvani Kumar  

Eliminated

22

CA. Khurana Gaurav Singh

Eliminated

Who is winning WIRC?

Would you like to share your views on the WIRC candidates?  Are all current WIRC members safe, and will they return to BKC?  WIRC is down by...